CODI 504 Voice Disorders
Treatment of Neurogenic Voice Disorders
Spasmodic Dysphonia
-
Ludlow (1995) - defines spasmodic dysphonia as a focal dystonia affecting
the laryngeal muscle control during speec
-
Exact site of lesion and cause is not known - may be in basal ganglia
-
At one time, etiology thought to be psychogenic
-
Stress does seem to exacerbate symptoms; therapy can sometimes alleviate
symptoms
Characteristics
-
Affects men & women in equal numbers
-
Onset often in middle age
-
Onset is variable
-
Associated with URI
-
Traumatic event
-
Slow insidious process progressing from hoarseness to interrupted phonation
-
Symptoms absent in vegetative function & in speech that does not require
phonation
Adductor Spasmodic Dysphonia
-
Spasm or sudden contraction of laryngeal musculature causes sudden closure
(adduction) of vocal folds
-
Struggle/strain to talk with intermittent voice arrests
-
Varying degrees of hoarseness, harshness, tremor or creaking, choked, tense,
squeezed voice
-
Loudness & pitch variations, intermittent aphonia
Abductor Spasmodic Dysphonia.
-
Intermittent episodes of breathy dysphonia
-
Sudden drops in pitch
-
Vowel prolongations
-
Delay in voice onset after voiceless productions
-
Difficulty with transitions from voiceless to voiced phonemes
Adductor SD vs other hyperfunctional dysphonias
-
Voice symptoms similar to:
-
Vocal abuse/misuse dysphonia
-
Psychogenic dysphonia
-
Muscle Tension Dysphonia (MTD)
-
Differences
-
SD is not intermittent - never goes away completely
-
Onset is gradual
-
Abrupt voice breaks are common
-
Voice better in AM (dystonias go away during sleep)
-
Not apparent during singing
-
Voice may improve when using alcoholic beverages
-
Can be distinguished from MTD spectrally
Treatment
-
Very resistant to treatment including voice therapy
-
Recurrent laryngeal nerve section
-
5 years after surgery SD recurs in over 50%
-
Dystonia either resets or worsens in unoperated side
-
Anterior laryngoplasty & vocal fold thinning
-
Some positive results with circumlaryngeal massage but effects temporary
-
Treatment of choice is Botox
Botox Treatment
-
Adductor SD receives bilateral or unilateral injections in TA
-
Post-injection voice is mildly breathy followed by 2-6 months of complete
relief
-
Abductor SD requires bilateral injections into PCA
-
Requires injections more frequently (every 3-4 months)
-
Subtypes - those with mixed dystonias & those with tremor do not respond
as well to Botox
Vocal Fold Paralysis
-
Bilateral - results in aphonia & vulnerable open airway
-
Swallowing therapy to protect airway
-
Tracheotomy for severe cases
-
Unilateral - breathy, dysphonic or aphonic voice
-
Spontaneous recovery in cases of trauma in first 8 months post-onset
-
Temporary solutions for better voice include using higher pitch, masking
to increase effort & intensity, digital manipulation and head position
-
Injections of paralyzed vocal fold including fat, Teflon, collagen
-
Thyroplasty, nerve grafts
-
Amplification
Therapy for Hypofunctional Voice
-
Includes bowing, paralyzed or weak vocal folds associated with neurogenic
disease (Parkinson's)
-
Use of reflexive behaviors that result in closure including coughing
throat clearing, grunting, laughing
-
Pushing, pulling, isometrics during phonation
-
Vocal function exercises
-
Lee Silverman Voice Therapy
-
Improve function of other valves to compensate (articulatory precision,
oral resonance)